Disclaimer - I am in no way a die-hard fan of Tun Dr M.
HOWEVER, when I read Justice Ian Chin's telling of the 'bootcamp humiliation', it sort of left me with a, 'so what?'
…
The camp training methods as dictated in the post above really sounds a lot like the Kem Jati Negara styled, nation-building shit that most national service participants, the public servants, and people who're crazy enough to take up large awareness training sessions would have to do lor. If you've been to one of those experiential type, outdoor, ropes obstacle course training, the so-called 'humiliation' is PART of the training, and … I mean, I'm no Justice with a double or triple law degree, but I would know I'd come out from these camps in one piece, learning how to be a better person and NOT necessarily loving the company or the person who sanctioned the training in the first place.
Team building rigour is HARDLY a boot camp. The word 'boot camp' alone gives me the images of chilling torture chambers, where you are required to strip naked and shower together with people you hate, and then put through rigourous hot-cold 'therapies', and a series of other inhumane tortorous processes all with the objectives of brainwashing you into fear-based obedience. Those kind of things are humiliating and deserve 'justice served'.
But teenage - corporate level team building training structures are meant to be positive-attitude, team-player spirit fostering programs, and seriously, I've never met anyone who came out of the standard 'keep an egg for five days of the camp duration and make sure it comes out in a piece' game, thinking it was a 'mind-softening method designed to force someone into obedience', humiliating process, until of course, Justice Ian Chin went to testify and told his alleged experiences of being tortured at his version of the terrifying boot camp (May 26-30 in some year, 4 days mind you, BOOT CAMP! Hah!)
I've been to those training camps when I was in school, when I went to university, and at those standard orientation courses for new company employees. Upon arrival, you get the course facilitator or camp coach telling us in some ganas fierce trainer voice to drop our phones into a bag and for the 3 days to two weeks we were there we were not allowed to contact our family members. And then, you know, the egg drop game, the scolding in front of the participants, the appointment of the usual youngest, most inexperienced person in the group as team leader, the one who demonstrates the least leadership qualities in the entire team as captain… been there done that…
And all I know is that these camps have been there forever and I've attended one or two of them either by compulsion (company employment requirements or personal participation). I don't look back and think it was humiliating.
…
Some people say that judges should not be sent to boot camp like this. Apparently They don't need the training. Or some people who're just keen to say that Tun M was evil anyway can get a little more extreme and say that 'judges aren't meant to be team players'. That judges are high level officials and they like MPs and ministers don't need these boot camps. That's just blatantly opposing for the heck of opposing - I'd rather say that the whole system should be fair and that everyone in the government service, whether you're the PM, a minister, an MP or the lowest toilet cleaner in a gahmen office building, should all attend these camps, if they're so called compulsory.
Also I live by the if you choose to be a citizen of Rome, then you might as well do as the Romans say and don't bitch so much about it. I mean if I worked at to a crazy company (who paid me thousands of ringgit a month and gave me a datukship along the way) where it was a requirement for me as an employee I have to attend some stupid 2-day etiquette training on how to talk to the public and how to put on makeup, I WOULD attend it. It doesn't mean I'd take everything that the trainer tells me in the training as the bible. I, being master of my ownself, would be the final judge of what I will take home from the training.
Personally I thought that Justice Chin, being a man of great intellectual superiority, would have been smart enough to be able to discern and judge for himself what stuff to take home from the meetings he had to suffer through (including witnessing a superior judge apologizing to a junior office employee).
But then again lah, I'm not a judge lah. Maybe if I were a judge, its super important for me to look good, be great, be some high and mighty JUDGE all the time kua. Even in a training session, camp, ropes obstacles course. Whatever.
…
You know I blogged this because I'm pissed that someone as 'dignified', intelligent, experienced and admired as Datuk Ian Chin can be so stupid as to release a press statement with that sort of things and calling it 'humiliation'. He should have just shut up and I would have been happy to live with the belief that Tun really had did all the terrible things, cos it was BELIEVABLE just by looking at Ian Chin's grim and proper face. After reading the court proceeding, Chin just sounds like some stupid whiney kid who can't get over the fact that he had to apologize to a puny clerk at some weekend camp that happened over a decade ago.
…
Ok lah just had to add this. ABout that indoctrination shit for judges telling them to be aligned and keep their allegiance to the government. You're working for the Government lah, what'd you expect? Some training where you'll be attending some lovey-dovey 'i'm so great' basking in spa-comfortness, and them some lovely woman pitching into your ear into how wonderful the opposition party is kah? SOrry ok I'm sounding a little crude, but I think if I'm working for Google, I'd damn well be expecting that attending a function closed to Google staff will be all talking about how Google is great, and how Google beats the shit out of Yahoo. I don't think we'll be doing anything about getting close to Yahoo and loving the enemies at Altavista. We already have church and religion to tell us to love our enemies and neighbours, governments like any other corporations are selfish… and I can't say this enough lah, YOUR BRAIN IS YOUR OWN LAH, who ask you so stupid to get brainwashed for 10 years? Don't like something, don't ikut lah, who ask you to go and follow so blindly for so long?
(OK I'm hoping he comes up with more stories like being forced to sign no-guilty verdicts on killers and murderers… but if he comes back with more, I was forced to bring tea to the tea lady who was at the same camp at me and I WAS HUMILIATED boo hoo story… man…)
I'm pissed lah ok. Cos I so believed Justice Ian Chin and now he's sounding like a kiddo whiner and I'm just sick of all of this. We have stupid politicians, lousy ex leaders, corrupted town councillers and ex prime ministers, and now…. childish judges. Lovely country we have. Boleh benar lah Malaysia. Hebat.